PSYC 367/WmSt 366:  Gender Issues in Psychology

Spring 2004            Virginia Norris, Ph.D.

All dates are subject to change.  Announcements in class supersede internet material.


Gender Issues--Chapter 8
Hormonal and Reproductive Connections
Women
Men

WOMEN

  • Puberty
    • Biological Correlates of Puberty
      • Age at Onset
      • Breast Development
      • Fat Spurt
      • Menarche
    • Psychological Effects
      • Menarche
      • Bodily focus
      • Code of Silence
    • Breast Development
    • Teasing
    • Anxiety
    • Double Bind
    • Weight and Body Image
      • Weight Gain
      • "Long Lithe Look"
      • Meaning
    • Early versus Late Maturation
      • Body Image
      • Social Effects
      • Academic Effects
  • Premenstrual Syndrome
    • Definition
      • Original definition (R. T. Frank, 1931) of Premenstrual Tension was mood changes occurring in the 3 to 4 days immediately preceding menstruation.
        • Included
          • depression
          • anxiety
          • irritability
          • low self-esteem
      • Later Definitions became much broader
        • Often included
        • behaviors and
        • physical and intellectual functioning
    • Four Types of Studies of PMS
      • Correlation of behaviors with cycle phase
        • 49% of crimes committed by women
        • 45% of calling in sick
        • 46% of psychiatric admissions
        • 52% of accident/emergency admissions
        • 54% of mothers of children brought to a clinic for a minor cold
        • BUT, 8 days equal about 29% of the days in a usual menstrual cycle THUS 29% of these behaviors should occur during these 8 days. Behaviors left to explain:
          • 20% crimes
          • 16% of calling in sick
          • 17% psychiatric admissions
          • 23% accident-emergency admissions
          • 25% taking child to clinic for minor cold
        • AND
          • We know that STRESS can affect the hormonal cycle
          • thus bringing on the menstrual cycle.
        • No decrements have been found for physical or intellectual performance during this 8-day period.
      • Retrospective Questionnaires--Report of symptoms and moods at various phases
        • Focus of Questions
        • Illusory Correlation
        • Social Conditioning
      • Self-Reports Made by Women Throughout Their Cycle
        • Positive mood around the time of ovulation
        • Anxiety, irritability, depression, fatigue, and headaches premenstrually
        • Problems with Self-Reports
          • Demand Characteristics
          • Negative findings disappear when respondents are not aware that PMS is being studied
      • Projective Techniques
        • Participants tell stories to the experimenter at regular intervals throughout the cycle
        • Stories premenstrually contain more anxiety about death, mutilation, and separation
        • Stories midcycle (ovulation) contain higher levels of self-esteem and self-confidence
    • Problems with PMS Research
      • 1. Virtually all data is correlational.
      • 2. PMS is vaguely defined.
      • 3. Documented cultural influences.
      • 4. Subtle problem of interpretation
      • 5. Failure to investigate effective coping techniques
    • Conclusions
      • There is evidence
        • that some women do experience cyclic mood changes but so do some men,
        • that these changes are primarily hormonal is not likely, and
        • that they are culturally determined is more likely, but NOT proved.
      • No matter what the source of these mood changes
          • they probably affect far less than 50% of women,
          • most women cope effectively with these changes by sleeping more or by keeping busy or by eating foods that do not promote water retention, AND
          • these mood changes DO NOT affect physical and intellectual abilities, i.e., work output is as high in quantity and quality as at any other time of the month.
    • Documented Menstrual Cycle Fluctuations
      • Increased sensitivity of the senses
  • Menopause
    • Physiology
      • Rats
      • Women
  • Changes
  • sexual behavior
  • Decline in sexual interest
  • Painful intercourse
  • Hot Flashes, etc.
  • Periods of profuse sweating, feeling very hot, and becoming flushed
  • Associated with a surge of lutenizing hormone and/or increased adrenal activity
  • Occur in 60-70% of women
  • Correlates of Hot Flashes
  • tingling sensations
  • insomnia
  • nervousness
  • muscle and joint aches
  • fatigue
  • dizziness
  • headaches
  • heart palpitations
  • Depression
  • About 30% of women who have had depression in the past will have a small increase in the number of depressive episodes and the number of depressive symptoms
        • These are related to the frequency of the hot flashes and to the women’s feelings about her loss of fertility.
        • Women who have not had prior episodes of depression are not at increased risk of depression following menopause.
      • Etc.
        • Women are more likely to report distressing menopausal changes if they are less educated, not working, and in poor physical health.
        • These changes will be reported as more distressing if either she or her culture has a negative stereotype of postmenopausal women.
        • Having severe and/or frequent life stress, e.g., death, illnesses, retirement, also increases distressing menopausal symptoms.
      • Osteoporosis
        • Loss of bone structure
        • Makes breakage more likely
        • Can lead to the "dowager’s hump"
        • Cigarette smoking, alcohol consumption, and low activity levels seem to increase the rate of osteoporosis
        • Estrogen therapy, exercise, calcium supplements, and being slightly overweight decrease the rate
          • Estrogen Replacement Therapy (aka HRT)
            • Although decreases the risk of osteoporosis and heart disease, it may increase the risk of breast cancer
            • On many regimens the menses continue
            • Personal decision--handout that discusses risks and benefits
MEN
  • Puberty
  • Physical Changes
  • Spermarche
  • Hormonal Cycles
  • Circadian Cycles
  • Hormonal changes that regularly recur during each 24-hour period
  • For males the highest testosterone levels occur at night
        • Peaks in testosterone levels occur 30 to 10 minutes before REM
        • Related to adrenal activity not testes
        • Females also have testosterone cycles with the highest levels in the morning
      • Behavioral Correlates
        • Females
          • Orgasm most likely to occur when sexual activity takes place after midday
        • Males
          • Positive moods more likely at midday and late afternoon
          • Cognitive task performances better in the morning
      • Monthly Cycles in Males
        • Little research in this area
          • One study found monthly cycles in male mental patients
            • mental symptoms
            • activity levels
            • body temperature
            • incidents of fevers
          • Another study found rhythmic changes in testosterone levels
            • ranged from 8 to 30 days
              • consistent for each individual
            • varied from 9% to 28% change
              • again, consistent for each individual
      • Annual Cycles in Females
        • Ovarian activity seems to be suppressed during the winter
      • Annual Cycles in Males
        • Testosterone reaches a peak somewhere between July and November
        • younger men have earlier seasonal peaks
        • Lowest testosterone levels are between February and June
      • Possible Correlates with Annual Cycles
        • Small annual rhythms in several behaviors have been identified
        • Annual peaks in these behaviors generally occur between May and November
    • Reproductive Senescence
        • Aging males have declining levels of testosterone
          • Decline in level is evident by age 44
        • Estrogen levels may increase
          • particularly in males with higher levels of body fat
      • Changes in Sexual Behavior
        • Decline in testosterone is not directly related to decline in sexual activity
        • Injections of testosterone will not restore the sexual activity of older males to levels typical of younger males
        • However, regular sexual activity may maintain youthful levels of testosterone in older men
      • Testosterone Treatment
        • Androgen treatment for 45 to 60 year old males can lead to
        • a decrease in neuroticism
        • an increase in extroversion, and
        • an increase in masculine self-image
        • Improvements in cognitive performance have also been shown
    • Male Menopause
      • There are real problems with this work
      • More recent studies indicate this is a social/cultural phenomenon, not a biological/hormonal factor.
    HAVE A NICE DAY!